1. LandOffer
  2. Blog
  3. All articles
  4. How to Compare Two Tech Job Offers When Salary, Equity, and Benefits Differ

Job search

How to Compare Two Tech Job Offers When Salary, Equity, and Benefits Differ

Normalize the period, keep equity and target bonuses separate, annualize employee costs and test practical constraints before choosing between tech offers.

9 min readLandOffer team

Compare two tech job offers by putting their terms on the same time horizon, then separating stated cash, conditional compensation, employee costs and practical constraints. A salary, a four-year stock grant and an employer-paid benefit are different things. A combined total can hide the timing, conditions or practical constraint that determines your choice.

Start with the actual offer documents and the questions they leave open. Use the same categories for each role, including location and working schedule. If neither opportunity fits, browse recent roles on LandOffer.ai while preserving this comparison as a record of what you need from the next offer.

Two offer folios sit on one workbench, with salary sheets, separate equity sleeves and benefits booklets.

Set a common comparison period

Sources checked October 22, 2026: Fidelity's offer-evaluation guide recommends considering non-salary benefits, career development, work environment and commuting alongside pay. The task is to decide which package fits your priorities, not simply find the largest displayed number.

Pick a period before doing arithmetic. For an initial comparison, you might use the first twelve months of employment and a separate recurring-year view. A sign-on payment can improve the first period without increasing recurring salary. A grant covering several years should not enter the first-year cash column at its full headline amount.

Record each input with its source: offer letter, compensation attachment, plan document or a dated clarification. Mark missing information as unknown rather than zero so the next question remains visible. Zero says there is no amount; unknown says the information is not established. Those states lead to different questions and can change the comparison.

LandOffer.ai publishes this guide. We reviewed current public educational sources without inspecting private offers, signing in to financial accounts, valuing shares or advising on a particular person's taxes or insurance. Both cases below are original fiction. Their arithmetic is a teaching model, not payroll, investment advice or a recommendation to accept a real job.

Keep conditional pay outside the cash subtotal

Read what each component represents. A base salary is a stated rate for work; it is not a lifetime payment promise. A target bonus depends on its rules and actual payout. A sign-on payment may have a payment date, eligibility requirements or repayment conditions. Keep those details attached instead of treating every amount as equally available.

Fidelity's vesting explanation, dated March 18, 2026, describes how equity and employer retirement contributions may depend on time or other requirements. Ask what vests, when, and what happens on departure. A future benefit that requires continued service should remain distinguishable from salary paid during that service.

Stock options also differ from shares or cash. Fidelity's stock-option guide describes a right to buy shares at a specified price after applicable vesting. A count of options cannot be converted into spendable compensation without the relevant terms. Do not assume a future sale, a favorable market price or immediate liquidity.

For a real grant, obtain its type, units, vesting and settlement rules, any exercise price and expiry, and applicable sale restrictions. Leave tax treatment and individual valuation outside a simple offer spreadsheet unless you have established them appropriately. Keep an unanswered grant term visible instead of supplying a dollar estimate you cannot support.

Worked comparison: first-year cash is not the whole package

Fictional case: Ada compares two engineering offers. Both roles are stipulated to permit her home location and meet her required schedule. She assumes twelve months of employment and receipt of the stated sign-on amounts under their conditions. The companies, packages and household assumptions are invented.

Comparison field Offer A: established platform team Offer B: smaller product team
Annual base $160,000 $172,000
First-year sign-on $10,000 $5,000
Stated cash under the assumptions $170,000 $177,000
Target bonus, kept separate 10% of base: $16,000 target 15% of base: $25,800 target
Equity description $120,000 grant reference over four years; stipulated first vesting portion 25%. 20,000 private-company options; exercise price and sale route unresolved.
Employee health premium $180 per month for the selected tier $320 per month for the same tier
Modeled commuting cost $120 per month $0 under her remote-work assumption
Modeled commuting time Three hours per week over 46 weeks None in this limited model
Work preference More relevant platform architecture exposure Broader feature ownership; less platform depth

Ada annualizes the listed employee premiums: $180 × 12 = $2,160 for A and $320 × 12 = $3,840 for B. She annualizes commuting cost as $1,440 for A. Subtracting only those listed costs from the stipulated first-year cash gives $166,400 for A and $173,160 for B, a $6,760 difference favoring B in this model.

That subtraction is not take-home pay. It excludes taxes, employee retirement contributions, actual medical care, other living costs and any repayment event. Premiums may have payroll tax effects that this arithmetic does not model. The result simply makes the listed inputs comparable on one stated basis.

She also creates a recurring-year view without sign-on: $156,400 for A and $168,160 for B after the same listed annual costs. The difference becomes $11,760. Treating A's larger sign-on as recurring would have hidden that change.

The equity entry remains separate. Twenty-five percent of A's stipulated $120,000 reference is $30,000, but that calculation is not a guaranteed sale value or cash payout. B's 20,000 options remain a unit count with unanswered terms. Neither enters Ada's cash subtotal. The bonus targets are also recorded without assuming payout.

Her full decision memo reads:

I prefer B under these fictional assumptions because its stated cash after the listed costs better fits my budget, and both roles satisfy my location and schedule requirements. I am giving up some platform-depth exposure that attracts me to A. I have not counted target bonuses as earned, the grant reference as realized cash or private options as a known dollar amount. Before any actual acceptance, I would review sign-on conditions, benefit documents and the equity terms that remain unresolved. This preference is not a claim that B has the greater eventual investment value.

An executed offline Python calculation reproduced the annual premiums, both first-year and recurring figures, target-bonus arithmetic and A's 25% reference. It also calculated 138 modeled commuting hours for A. Time stays in its own column; we did not assign those hours an invented salary value or test an actual journey.

Compare employee costs and coverage on the same basis

HealthCare.gov's cost guide explains the difference between premiums and costs incurred when receiving care, including deductibles and other cost sharing. Its page addresses Marketplace shopping; those definitions help organize questions, but do not establish the terms of a particular employer plan.

Compare the same coverage tier and period. An individual premium at one employer and a family premium at another are not equivalent inputs. A monthly figure and a per-paycheck deduction also need normalization using the actual number of deductions, not an assumed payroll calendar.

Obtain the Summary of Benefits and Coverage and the employee contribution information for the relevant options. HealthCare.gov describes the SBC as a standardized way to compare coverage. Match the plan year, named option and coverage tier; a recruiting brochure may omit the employee rate or the coverage detail you need.

A premium comparison alone cannot establish which plan costs less overall. Keep deductibles, cost-sharing rules, out-of-pocket limits, networks, covered services and start dates visible. Do not add a deductible to an out-of-pocket maximum as though both are independent bills you must always pay. Actual use and the plan's rules matter.

The same discipline applies to retirement benefits. Record the employer contribution formula, participation requirements and vesting, then keep it apart from current spending money. Avoid adding an employer's estimated benefit cost directly to your personal cash budget. What the company spends and what you can use are different measures.

Worked evidence decision: remove an infeasible offer before scoring perks

Separate fictional case: Milo initially sees Offer R at $185,000 base and Offer S at $178,000. He cannot relocate from Colorado under his stipulated circumstances. His first record labels R's location permission and both family-plan contributions unknown. He does not declare R the winner because its base is $7,000 higher.

He prepares questions, then the example stipulates that the following documents and replies arrive. These are invented inputs, not contacts we made or documents from real employers.

Decision item Offer R's stipulated clarification Offer S's stipulated clarification Completed interpretation
Work location Remote work permitted from California only; relocation would be required. Colorado home location permitted in the written arrangement. R fails Milo's current location constraint.
Family-tier employee premium $600 per month $420 per month Annualize to $7,200 and $5,040; do not compare against individual coverage.
Benefit evidence Contribution sheet available; applicable SBC not yet supplied. Contribution sheet and named plan-year SBC supplied. Keep R's coverage questions unresolved rather than infer equivalence.
Working schedule On-call expectations not specified. Rotation frequency described; actual escalation load still unknown. S has more schedule detail; workload remains uncertain.
Equity A recruiting estimate without grant details No equity component stipulated Do not turn R's estimate into current spendable cash or mark missing grant terms complete.
Current choice Higher salary but an incompatible required move Fits the stipulated location; remaining work questions identified Retain S for final review; stop treating R as feasible under its current terms.

The annual family-premium difference is $2,160, favoring S before care costs. It does not reverse the base-salary difference by itself, and no complete medical-cost estimate has been made. More importantly, a favorable equity story would not resolve R's location requirement. Milo checks feasibility before assigning preference scores.

His completed, unsent clarification note reads:

Thank you for supplying the location and benefits information. My current comparison uses the same family coverage tier and a twelve-month period. I understand R would require a move and S permits my stipulated Colorado location. For S's final review, please confirm the benefits effective date and identify the applicable plan option and employee contribution schedule. I would also like the on-call rotation, expected response times, escalation support and any travel requirements in writing. I am keeping unanswered items separate rather than treating them as included benefits or an approved exception.

His finished decision is retain S for review; do not rely on an exception to R's location rule. It is a practical conclusion from the invented facts, not an instruction for a real household or a prediction about either employer. If Milo's relocation constraint changed, he would revisit the comparison instead of carrying forward an obsolete exclusion.

A missing benefits pocket and an unconfirmed map location remain separate from a closed equity packet.

Finish with a decision you can explain

A useful comparison can say which offer you prefer, what you are giving up and which unknown could still change the choice. Keep hard requirements separate from preferences: an attractive learning opportunity might outweigh a modest cash difference, but it cannot silently authorize a location the employer does not permit.

Save the inputs and assumptions with your decision memo. Recalculate when a term changes; do not overwrite the earlier version and lose the reason your preference moved. One defensible comparison is more useful than a total-compensation number that mixes periods, conditions and costs.

Browse recent roles on LandOffer.ai if neither offer fits, and use your comparison to identify one concrete gap to investigate next: salary basis, permitted location, work scope or benefit evidence.

Sources and Further Reading